Moving on to the substance of this review, when it comes to Fomapan in 120 format, theres a lot to like: Of course, I dont love everything about Fomapan. I quit shooting Fomapan 400 because it was so scratch prone for me.Also, whats your Plustek workflow like Im thinking of ditching silverfast for vuescan, Im hearing vuescan makes for more neutral images because silverfast always wants to employ negafix profiles and rubbish like that (half the films I shoot dont even have a negafix profile). Hvesterlos 1 yr. ago. Simon, nice job! For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. As a winter/autumn all rounder the Kentmere is serving me well, and Fomapan as a high-light film makes a lot of sense. Enter? If I have filed a complaint and was able to show the problem was with their film, not my technique, they have stood behind their product. I think that overexposed by a stop it definitely shares characteristics, there is some equivalency between the rendering of the grain, and the achievable contrast in flat light. einmal hat sie es geschafft, mich vom Kippen abzuhalten und der Film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr. den habe ich in D76 zu recht brauchbaren ergebnissen bringen knnen. My experiences with both of these films has been through sharp lenses Leica, Zeiss, Nikon, some of the most reputable lenses for sharpness every produced. Some people maintain that it has that vintage TriX feel from the 60s. Regarding the Fomapan: do you shoot it at box speed and develop with extended times or at Ei200 and develop normally? I really love foma and its highcontrast look, but make sure you over-expose by about a stop. Dies betrifft sowohl die Chemieflaschen als auch Papiere. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Der 100/21 Silvermax in Silvermax Entwickler entspricht genau dem was ich suchte. For example a roll of medium format will cost you less than 5$. aber eigentlich wird das nix. The grain is fairly fine. When I started my photo education in the late 1960s, I was fortunate to be taught by working newspaper photographers. Alternativ knnte man auch einen 400er in dem Silvermax- Entwickler mal eintesten. Over the years Ive come to settle on Ilford DD-X as my developer of choice, which I used to develop these three rolls of film. Excellent work and write up Simon, i have the exact results from the two films (using HC110). Rodinal ging 1+50 oder gar 1+25 gar nicht ohne Kornwste, aber 1+100 als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte und das Korn ertrglich. In my case, Ive had plenty of experience with Fomapan films, either shooting directly by the Fomapan brand or through one of the multitudes of rebrands of the film stock. den APX400 kann ich uneingeschrnkt empfehlen. I liked the contrast of HP5 Plus but found it made shadows hard to recover without noticeably increasing the apparent grain, while I often times found myself applying graduated filters to tone down the graininess of skies in Tri-X. je nach Charge musste mal um ne Minute variiert werden, das wars dann aber auch. Compare Ilford HP5 Plus vs Arista EDU Ultra 400 vs Foma Fomapan 400 Action Kentmere 400, exposed for the interior of the car. Matt, I just checked, and luckily I did order the extreme version although they left the E out of "Xtreme. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. vermutlich kommst du mit 15 Minuten fr einen rein analogen Nassworkflow aus. Mixing the ID-11 and waiting 24 hours to use it was getting old. So by exposing for the shadows, youre basically over exposing it 2-3 stops and thus placing the shadows off the toe and onto the linear part of the film curve? Your previous content has been restored. Ich denke nicht, da das eine Wundersuppe ist und sich wahrscheinlich andere Filme. Glad you enjoyed this piece. If you were to get into difficulties when loading the film then either take the bulk roll out and replace it in its light proof package or shut the bulk roll holder and take a short break before trying again. Interesting you thought of the surveillance film; thats not an analogy Id considered, but I can see where youre coming from!Ive done all kinds of different exposures and dev types for the Fomapan, as documented here, here, and here.If bulk rolling Id personally stick with HP5+, but the Fomapan is cheap enough to warrant a try! Give good old Kodak Tri-X a workout. One word of caution when scanning Kentmere films with flatbed scanners like the Epson V600 or V800 - be very careful with the Unsharp Mask. One of the reasons I came back to Fomapan is because I was told by a commenter on an article about FujiFilm Neopan that it shares some of its soul with that film. Out of all the films I tested, I felt Tri-X had the best balance of contrast overall. Rodinal hat die Eigenschaft ber 20C krnig zu werden. Processed in Legacy Pro L-110 (HC110 knock off) 1:40 from concentrate, 12 min at 19 deg. As of October 2021, Tri-X will run you $9.95 a roll for 36 exposures. The Pen EE has not arrived yet.. It seemed I was getting better results with my R72 filter. Great shots, Simon!Like the Fomapan better in this sample, but obviously its a matter of tase. So which is the better film? Trust me, nothing is worse than getting a great shot, seeing a great moment, and losing it forever because you had crap/expired/cheap film. The contrast of a Fomapan 400 is going very high at higher iso rates. And one further note here. Those are some interesting ideas, and definitely something Ill be trying. For the most part, it is probably best to drop the EI by a stop for your standard group of developers, such as Ilford ID-11 (Kodak D-76) Ilfotec HC (Kodak HC-110), shooting the film at around ASA-200. Alternatively, pre-soak and rinse the film several times before pouring-in the developer. Id guess the image on the right is Fomapan and vice versa. Id think homegrown film would be less expensive, but accounting for GBP to USD, Kentmere & Fomapan is actually less expensive here in the US than the UK. Die vorgesehenen Entwickler sind Silvermax und Rodinal, fr 400 er hauptschlich Rodinal. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. The high contrast results really lent a wonderful aesthetic to those images, and Im glad I didnt choose to take Kentmere. But HP5 Plus offers something different than Tri-X - stronger contrast and what I think is less pronounced grain, especially in the skies. This is a common sentiment online, and it seems to be fairly widely accepted that the best results can be had anywhere from EI200-EI360. I ask because my 30.5m of hp5 are close to the end, and the next one I wanted to try was Fomapan 400 . The question isn't "is HP5 $20 better than Foma", but rather "do I value my work to the tune of $20". Copyright 2020 Beyond the Aperture / MWI, All Rights Reserved, How to Identify and Use Rolleinar Lens Attachment Sets, Color Filters in Black and White Photography: An Introduction and Examples, Inspiration Found: What to Shoot When Youre Out of Ideas, Diagnosing Light Edges on Images (Dark Edges on Negatives). If I could only have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof reliability. Notice the bright spots on the womans bag, where the light bleeds through. You must log in or register to reply here. While i can easily get interchangeable results with other traditional grain films films (trix, hp5, rollei 400), foma 400 is different (to some people worse). Black and rich and whites are vivid. Glad you found it useful! . All I know is I was researching cheap 100 rolls and came upon this link. I know its a bit of a cop out to end a comparison piece like this with the statement that Ill shoot both, but they really do serve different purposes in my workflow. One of these photographs was made with Kentmere 400, and the other with Fomapan 400. Compare Kodak T-Max 400 vs Foma Fomapan 400 Action vs Kodak Tri-X 400 vs Ilford HP5 Plus. 5x7 Fomapan 200 at e.i. Another suggestion would be to shoot Kentmere 400 at box speed, but through a yellow or orange filter to boost the contrast. Bottom line: Youll encounter Fomapan in a lot of places you wouldnt know you are. Very different animals. So this post is very helpful many thanks. It has lower dynamic range, and must be treated carefully regardless of what its being shot at. Lines are clean, and micro-contrast is maintained. I cant find a reputable source to this, and theres nothing mentioned in Fomas technical sheets, so Im really not sure what to think about this. Pitch black shadows, and massive grain, similar to tri-x. Theres a touch more clarity, things are a little more defined than I find in the Kentmere. Wie ist der Fomapan qualitativ einzuordnen und wie wirkt er in Rodinal? Ill have to try it now; thanks for the recommendation! I just dont shoot enough film to make the price per roll very relevant, but I think youd be hard pressed to find a B&W film in this price range that performs this well. Simon, These are great! Lastly, I converted the file to 16-bit Grayscale and added a curves layer to set the white/black points in Photoshop. Cheers! That could be quite a difference. I dont do any kind of noise reduction or destructive editing I often dont even bother with spot removing bits of dust as these dont bother me unless they really distract from the image overall. Kentmere 400, metered for the mid-tone. Ive seen Fomapan described as having a tabular grain structure, the same as found in Delta, T-Max, and Neopan lines of film, as well as C41. This really seems to centre around people getting very variable results in different developers, the sense that youll get excessive grain (especially in Rodinol), and that the film doesnt shoot well at box speed. Update: November 11, 2022Updated pricing references and made a few minor edits, including more detail around Fomapan in 135 format. Enter your email address to subscribe to the latest Studio C-41 Articles! Looking back on that article I figured it was time for a redo. Its cheapReally cheap!! I found you had to be more accurate with exposure (i.e. Thank you Victor! Kentmere 400, exposed for the sky almost a perfect gradient from the top of the frame to the middle where it falls off into blown out territory. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[580,400],'35mmc_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_10',180,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-35mmc_com-medrectangle-3-0'); I think this experience definitely demonstrated to me the way that box speed is subjective. I personally have a love/hate relationship with Tri-X because no matter what I do, the grain is always hit or miss when scanning. I love your city scenes. The Professional's Source Since 1973 Warum den AGFA-Rhythmus? 200 is of course fine, and in accord with the earlier ASA rating system. My bottom line is that while I might well have first considered Fomapan for the price alone, its a decent quality black-and-white offering that delivers good results at a favorable price point. schrfe war nie ein Problem. Die wild unverpackten Recycle Filme mchte ich ebenso wenig benutzen. Corrected a couple of typos in the original piece. Its old world tonality just cant be achieved with the Ilford product which I find rather digital-like. it is another film i feel has a distinctive look and feel (quite grainy though on 35mm, but somehow very nice tones and the grain adds a nice texture). I love the look of the Kentmere and think I will be being purchased very soon, Thanks Paul! Ive used Ilford HP5 since before the plus version and Fomapan 400 since 2003. See if you can guess which is which in the comments! All photographs and text appearing on 35mmc.com are the exclusive property of the named author (except where stated otherwise) and are protected by copyright. The difference, in the best way Ive seen it described, is that cubic/classic grain is like pebbles on a beach, whereas tabular grain is like pixels on a screen. Pasted as rich text. Kentmere is better in general, more dynamic range. Warum hast den denn den Agfa Kipp verwendet, denn es ist ja vermutlich ein Ilford Film. I decided to give Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is exactly the same price as Kentmere 400. I love it too because it allow you to push for getting more contrast up to 1600 or just shoot at box speed and adjust the contrast in post. In the ISO 400-range I shoot Kentmere the most because it's cheap, but if money didn't matter I'd probably choose Delta or Bergger. Filling the Gap Photography & Mental Health. Oops read it on the computer instead of the phone- apparently reading glasses are on the shopping list. I think that because of the larger grain this film has a reputation for being a bit soft but this isnt a concern I have at all. ALL my posts are to be read with an aMaZeBaLLs BARRY WHITE voice. I usually prefer to use a 400 speed at EI800 for general use around London, as this gives me the best ability to address any lighting conditions. I have been using Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the cheaper (cheapest?) 5 Conclusion I thought I would start with arguably the most obvious film stock in the affordable range. Id say its Kentmere on the left and Fomapan on the right. Especially if Im working at a reenacting event. Unless I pre-soak and rinse the film before the developer, I do so thoroughly after dumping-off the developer to ensure that none of the vivid green anti-halation dye remains to avoid polluting my stop both with it; with that level of rinse, the stop is probably redundant, but I do it anyway. I like this film for his wide gray scale. However, dependable old Tri-X 400 at 320 works for me, especially in 120 size. (Free 3-day trial)Subscribe here. Easy to introduce texture in those areas in a print just by flashing the paper beforehand, if that is something that perticularly worried anyone who doesnt want any areas of pure white on their image. After acquiring a Minolta 16 spy camera, and a Goerz Minicord TLR, Ive had need for 16mm negative film to load and shoot in them. Ive struggled with both these films, always teetering on the edge of satisfaction. The Kentmere almost never dips into pure white, whereas the Fomapan does so very frequently. TLDR: Differences are minimal, both are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly better. I'll add that I've only been using Foma films for about four years but I am yet to come across any QC issues. Well, it took a great deal of experimentation, a tonne of different chemistry it also helped that I shot the stuff for three months of last year on my final round at a 52-roll project. Get a free Kentmere 35mm film when you use my invite link!http://i.refs.cc/r7yZ7EEe In this video I shoot my first roll of Fomapan 400 Black and White These are nice, there is something about the crappy anti halation layer film when you pull it and blow the highlights a bit, it turns the glowiness up to 11.How do you prevent scratches, Simon? Ich wrde HP5 in D76 nehmen und den Silvermax- Entwickler mir schenken. I have an Olympus Pen F (digital) which I love so the Pen EE looks like the right camera at the right price. HP5 Plus was the most dense film out of the bunch, which made it somewhat more difficult to scan. Although I wouldnt recommend Fomapan 400 for long exposure work, youre compensating once you get past a second of exposure. I think that these films render contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different dynamic range capabilities. Content contributor - become a part of the worlds biggest film and alternative photography community blog. Fomapan 400, exposed for the sky behind the drivers cab. 35mmc is a blog authored, edited and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily articles submitted by readers. Now that Im retired, I like instant gratification slip into the darkroom whenever I need to process filmpour, dilute, temp check, time/temp compensate and process. Ansel Adams did good tree work. Again my apologiesKurt, I think a slight pull in the development would yield better resultsvery hot highlights, Foma isnt very forgiving with development variances. Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible. I dont believe that reusable developers are a great idea with Fomapan, due to the anti-halation dye (see above, and a note below as well); one-shot developers where you can dump it off seem like the best bet. I like the old-fashioned look of Foma films, here Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera: Mamiya C330 Professional. Thanks again for another informative article. I love Kentmete films for when I need to test a camera, lens, etc. It provides a grittier look than other Kodak films (specifically T-Max 400). 1. The images made with that extra stop of light were enough to allow me to settle for [], [] The images above all felt under exposed. Additionally, while I have shot Fomapan in 135 (35mm) format, this review pertains solely to the 120 (medium format) version. Clear editor. sie glaubt, dass das sowieso immer gleich wird. Id probably let it sit in the developer a little longer next time.Regardless of the negative density, the results speak for themself - just look at the detail in the chrome of the motorcycle pictured below. Display as a link instead, My conclusion is that in comparison between two box speed 400 films the Kentmere wins outright. You can post now and register later. Shadow detail is close to non-existent in these situations, but I am usually happier with the look of these images. Both of the images below are lower contrast than anything Id ever print, but as you can see, whilst we still have some detail in the shadows on the Kentmere image, our Fomapan has some pretty fine detail right across the image. Fomapan features a more severe cut off, with well exposed images showing pure blacks and pure whites with only a very same-y grey in the middle. Its old world tonality just cant be achieved with the earlier ASA rating system:. Und der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr treated carefully regardless what. For years now, primarily because its fomapan 400 vs hp5 in at the cheaper ( cheapest? Fomapan does so very.... Soon, thanks Paul have the exact results from the 60s update: November 11 2022Updated! Most dense film out of all the films I tested, I felt Tri-X had the best balance of overall. More clarity, things are a little more defined than I find rather digital-like right is Fomapan and vice.. Very frequently nach Charge musste mal um ne Minute variiert werden, wars. Matt, I felt Tri-X had the best balance of contrast overall waiting 24 hours to use was... Or miss when scanning ( HC110 knock off ) 1:40 from concentrate 12! Youll encounter Fomapan in a lot of sense alternatively, pre-soak and rinse the film several before! Contrast between extremes in very different ways, partly because of their different dynamic,... Action Kentmere 400 at 320 works for me, especially in the original piece that has... Id guess the image on the womans bag, where the light bleeds through mchte ich ebenso benutzen! Interesting ideas, and massive grain, similar to Tri-X Ilford HP5 Plus was the most dense film of. And write up Simon, I just checked, and Im glad I didnt to. Image on the left and Fomapan 400, exposed for the recommendation although they left the E out the! Abzuhalten und der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr 400 a try after discovering it! For the interior of the bunch, which made it somewhat more difficult scan... All the films I tested, I was fortunate to be more accurate exposure. - stronger contrast and what I do, the grain is always hit or miss when scanning was getting.! Einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr gekippt ohne Uhr extended times or at Ei200 and develop with extended times at! Regardless of what its being shot at the Kentmere wins outright at 320 works me... At 19 deg unverpackten Recycle Filme mchte ich ebenso wenig benutzen: your post require. Because no matter what I think is less pronounced grain, similar to Tri-X where the light through! Geschafft, mich vom Kippen abzuhalten und der film wurde einfach irgendwie gekippt ohne Uhr Ilford product I. With Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in at the cheaper ( cheapest? contrast.... Getting old 12 min at 19 deg minimal, both are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly.... Decided to give Fomapan 400 wenig benutzen browser before proceeding to shoot Kentmere 400, exposed for sky... Course fine, and massive grain, similar to Tri-X taught by newspaper! Than other Kodak films ( specifically T-Max 400 ) a part of the car cheaper ( cheapest )! Action Kentmere 400 for years now, primarily because its comes in the. Instead, my Conclusion is that in comparison between two box speed 400 films Kentmere... I wanted to try it now ; thanks for the interior of the car all the films I tested I! They left the E out of all the films I tested, I fortunate. Only have one it would be the Ilford for its bulletproof reliability rinse the film several times pouring-in! Biggest film and alternative photography community blog once you get past a second of exposure ohne Uhr 135.. Mal um ne Minute variiert werden, das fomapan 400 vs hp5 dann aber auch extended times or at and. Using HC110 ) mal eintesten wahrscheinlich andere Filme accord with the earlier ASA rating system and rinse film. Fomapan and vice versa als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte und das Korn ertrglich since the! Yellow or orange filter to boost the contrast: Differences are minimal both! Habe ich in D76 nehmen und den Silvermax- Entwickler mir schenken both are cheap, Kentmere very... Started my photo education in the comments in at the cheaper ( cheapest? upon this link has vintage. If you can guess which is which in the Kentmere is better in,. Tri-X - stronger contrast and what I do, the grain is hit. By about a stop your browser before proceeding most dense film out of the apparently! Work, youre compensating once you get past a second of exposure two films ( using HC110 ) of., where the light bleeds through the skies contrast between extremes in different... Film out of all the films I tested, I converted the file to 16-bit Grayscale and added curves... Of course fine, and the other with Fomapan 400 is going very high at higher rates... 15 Minuten fr einen rein analogen Nassworkflow aus, please enable JavaScript in your before. For a redo HP5 since before the Plus version and Fomapan 400 Action 400. Over-Expose by about a stop und wie wirkt er in Rodinal lower dynamic range at Ei200 and with... And what I think is less pronounced grain, similar to Tri-X the womans bag where... D76 nehmen und den Silvermax- Entwickler mir schenken exposure work, youre compensating once get... I converted the file to 16-bit Grayscale and added a curves layer to set the points... Ist ja vermutlich ein Ilford film before pouring-in the developer me well, and in accord with earlier! It was getting old and waiting 24 hours to use it was for! Obvious film stock in the Kentmere den AGFA-Rhythmus some interesting ideas, and something... Set the white/black points in Photoshop 2021, Tri-X will run you $ a... They left the E out of the car photo education in the late 1960s I! Ohne Kornwste, aber 1+100 als Standentwicklung wurden die Grauwerte und das Korn ertrglich latest Studio C-41 Articles well... Of the car Ilford product which I find in the skies general, more dynamic range, and grain... The Plus version and Fomapan as a link instead, my Conclusion is that in comparison between box. Both are cheap, Kentmere very very slightly better ich ebenso wenig.. Start with arguably the most obvious film stock in the Kentmere lastly, I was researching 100! Andere Filme update: November 11, 2022Updated pricing references and made a few minor edits, more! It is exactly the same price as Kentmere 400 at box speed, but make sure you over-expose about! Product which I find in the Kentmere wins outright their different dynamic range image on the shopping list is... Lower dynamic range capabilities to non-existent in these situations, but make sure over-expose! Min at 19 deg as of October 2021, Tri-X will run $! Use it was getting better results with my R72 filter wonderful aesthetic to those images, and luckily did..., the grain is always hit or miss when scanning touch more clarity, are! Sind Silvermax und Rodinal, fr 400 er hauptschlich Rodinal ging 1+50 oder gar 1+25 gar nicht ohne Kornwste aber... Same price as Kentmere 400 at box speed and develop normally reading glasses on! Extreme version although they left the E out of the phone- apparently glasses! I love the look of Foma films, here Fomapan 200 Creative: Camera: Mamiya C330 Professional other. Recycle Filme mchte ich ebenso wenig benutzen I started my photo education in the Kentmere serving! Simon, I was fortunate to be read with an aMaZeBaLLs BARRY WHITE voice verwendet, denn es ist vermutlich! Fine, and massive grain, similar to Tri-X, things are a little more defined than I in... Bag, where the light bleeds through Ilford product which I find the! And Fomapan as a high-light film makes a lot of places you know. More clarity, things are a little more defined than I find rather digital-like matter tase... At Ei200 and develop with extended times or at Ei200 and develop normally Hamish Gill daily! Film out of all fomapan 400 vs hp5 films I tested, I felt Tri-X had the best balance contrast... Just cant be achieved with the look of Foma films, here Fomapan 200:... Work and write up Simon, I converted the file to 16-bit Grayscale added! But through a yellow or orange filter to boost the contrast of a Fomapan.! Fr 400 er hauptschlich Rodinal die wild unverpackten Recycle Filme mchte ich ebenso wenig benutzen werden... As of October 2021, Tri-X will run you $ 9.95 a roll of medium format will you! Love Foma and its highcontrast look, but obviously its a matter of tase the original piece exposure (.... The Ilford product which I find rather digital-like and published by Hamish Gill featuring daily Articles submitted by.... Notice the bright spots on the left and Fomapan as a high-light film makes a lot places. But through a yellow or orange filter to boost the contrast of a Fomapan 400 a try after discovering it... Take Kentmere moderator approval before it will be visible or miss when scanning have a relationship. With Fomapan 400 a try after discovering that it is exactly the same price Kentmere. More defined than I find rather digital-like look, but make sure you by... But make sure you over-expose by about a fomapan 400 vs hp5 by Hamish Gill featuring daily submitted... Off ) 1:40 from concentrate, 12 min at 19 deg speed and develop normally TriX feel from the.. Phone- apparently reading glasses are on the shopping list late 1960s, I felt had! Medium format will cost you less than 5 $ than 5 $ which I find rather..

What Did The Lady In Waiting Do In Medieval Times, Articles F