Banished by the . Thank you! Books Finally, he involved the spouse of his brother Isodemus in adultery. He defiled them, assaulting them both in secret and in open view. The great verbal support that Arab heads of state once lavished on the Palestinians is no more; they have been mostly silent spectators to Israels war. The feud grew to such a level that Periander enacted a law that no one should harbour or speak with his son. In order to prove the validity of her spectral utterance, Melissa told the messengers that "Periander had put his loaves into a cold oven" (Hdt. Some of these Thrasybulus said nothing in response to the messenger, but took him out to a field where he cut off the tops of corn stalks and tossed them aside; he then sent the messenger back. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. The World History Encyclopedia logo is a registered trademark. He was the son of the first tyrant, Cypselus. Periander *Peri/andros ). Arming the soldiers under this pretext Cleisthenes prevented Isodemus from returning and became sole king himself, the most tyrannical and cruel of all his predecessors. He considered it "a most [2] Nevertheless, even then, the majority of the views preserved in Diogenes' account conform to a stereotypical view of depraved tyranny, even including an accusation of incest. The recent fulminations of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoan, even more vitriolic than those of Irans Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, attest to the extreme deterioration of a once important and long-lasting modus vivendi between Israel and Turkey. [7] The Ionian city was one of the few allowed to have its own sanctuary in Egypts territory (Herod., II, 178). Science 276, 1196-1197. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. Go to: Opposition to Bateson (Click Here), Go to: AIDS Treatment by Programmed Thrasybulus. In particular, the account given by Herodotus seems to corroborate the assumption. Some relate that a vessel with its freight was sent by Periander to Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus, and that, when it was wrecked in Coan waters, the tripod was afterwards found by certain fishermen. Miletus was an important center of philosophy and science, producing such men as Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes. Mayr concluded his "Essay Ecology and Evolution 16, 330-342. The analogy showed that violence could not be a one-time affair. You can ask !. corroborates the assertion. This article is about the tyrant of Miletus. seize the funding and publication power and send into academic exile those who would contend with them. . Aristotle described the legend in his work, The Politics, in which he stated, It is said that to Thrasybulus messenger, who had come for advice, Periander returned no answer; but while walking in a field, reduced all the ears of corn [aka grain] to one level by lopping off the tallest (Aristotle, Politics, Bekker number 1284a). Omissions? The so-called trade leagues in early Greek history and the Lelantine War. Israel has also made very considerable progress with European governments, if not so much with public opinion. Review" on "The My own epitaph on him is: In autumn 403, following skirmishes with a Spartan expedition under King Pausanias, a reconciliation was effected and democracy was restored. The recent Ctesias is a remarkable figure: he lived and worked in the Persian court and, as a doctor, tended to the world's most powerful kings and queens. He ordered two young men to go out at night by a certain road which he pointed out to them; they were to kill the man they met and bury him. 1946. Her ghost was cold and naked because Periander had not burned her clothes but buried them with her corpse, where they were or no use to her ghostly self. In 411 BC, in the wake of an oligarchic coup at Athens, the pro-democracy sailors at Samos elected him as a general, making him a primary leader of the successful democratic resistance to that coup. The above-cited extract illustrates how Isodemus, removed from office under false pretences, took refuge in Corinth. his stick, so cutting back the stems that stuck out above the rest. bias "that in recent years As they strolled along, Thrasybulus idly swatted the corn with his stick, so cutting back the stems that stuck out above the rest. COOK, R.M. As Periander was a successful tyrant who ran a stable and efficient government, it was natural that other despotic rulers in the ancient Greek world looked to him for advice and inspiration. Thrasybulus definition, Athenian patriot and general. Lloyd, James. Francis comments, Herodotus, and Diogenes Laertius citing him in his Lives of Eminent Philosophers, explicitly call Periander a xenos a guest-friend of Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus (Herod., I, 20; Diog. A nave unwillingness to face the difficulties and uncertainties in an area where there are SCHMIDT, R.V. Web. 5.92G). will be bit by the peers who review their Periander was the son of Cypselus, the founder of the Cypselid dynasty of Corinth. Herodotus wrote in the 5th century BCE, some 150 years after Periander's rule, and Aristotle was born almost 200 years after the death of Periander. hope that I will be refuted where my judgement is faulty, so that, in Now Isodemus was said to be ingenuous and honest by nature, while his brother Cleisthenes was devious. Periander cultivated friendly relations with Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus, and maintained ties with the kings of Lydia and Egypt. St. Petersburg State University, Institute of History; email: sergey-. Thrasybulus (Greek: ) was the tyrant of Miletus in the 7th century BC. Terms of Use It has assassinated Iranian nuclear scientists and bombed sites in Syria, Lebanon, and Sudan over the same time period, just as it has continually agitated for U.S. military strikes against Irans nuclear infrastructure. 5.92F.2 He had sent a herald to Thrasybulus and inquired in what way he would best and most safely govern his city. World History Publishing is a non-profit company registered in the United Kingdom. Thrasybulus was now the hero of the people; but a decree by which he secured the franchise for all his noncitizen followers was rescinded as illegal. After much negotiation (Periander had sent Lycophron's sister to persuade him to return, but this had failed), Lycophron agreed to return to Corinth on the condition that Periander lived out the rest of his life on Corcyra. A numismatic note on the Lelantian War. Following the war, Miletus and Lydia concluded an alliance. In that bizarre mix of divine intervention and mortal motivation that was early Greek history, it could hardly have happened any other way, for Periander's father had received a Delphic oracle that read: That man is fortunate who steps into my house, Otherwise he, being guilty of fratricide, would find it difficult to keep the tyranny and bequeath it to his children. I [1] ). One of the worst aspects When republishing on the web a hyperlink back to the original content source URL must be included. One might assume that the origin of the anecdote would be fixed by the presence in the story of the historical figures of Periander of Corinth and Thrasybulus of . Parnes near Athens. History of Biology 6, 155-165. somewhat similar to our modern election campaigns when one party comes into power, but the While walking through the wheat, he wondered why that messenger had come to him. Okay. It is. His position gave him special insight into the workings of Persian court life and access to the gossip and scandal surrounding Persian history and court politics, past and present. Machiavelli offers a view different from Thrasybulus. Aristotle views this story and its consequences from a political viewpoint, commenting: this policy is advantageous not only for tyrants, nor is it only tyrants that use it, but the same is the case with oligarchies and democracies as well; for ostracism has in a way the same effect as docking off the outstanding men by exile. Thrasybulus was an ally of Periander, the tyrant of Corinth. In Scena Periander. About hinting at the blame due to those whose faulty ideas have delayed scientific 54). review entitled "Theory and Speciation" Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, Fake Foreign News, Political Fervor, and Motivation for the American Revolution, The Dark World of Far-Right Conspiracy Theorists, Thomas Paine: Revolutionary Agitator and Forerunner of Freedom, Conspiracies, the Antigovernment Movement, and the Threat to the American Republic, The Power of Penmanship: Writing the Declaration of Independence. The collapse of Israels relationship with Turkey is more recent but also, one should think, a very serious liability to Israels policy in Gaza. The story goes that Thrasybulus led Periander's messenger into a cornfield outside the city of Miletus, and started reaping the tallest and best of the crop, throwing it away. It appears that the commercial prosperity of Perianders Corinth became so great that the tolls on goods entering its ports accounted for almost all government revenues. New stalks would grow up. This license lets others remix, tweak, and build upon this content non-commercially, as long as they credit the author and license their new creations under the identical terms. given anywhere near enough attention to the importance of the scientific (and Aristotles Politics contain reference to this same embassy, although according to the version of the philosopher from Stagira, it was Thrasybulus who had caused the mission to be sent: The story is that Periander, when a herald was sent to ask counsel of him, said nothing, but cut off the tallest ears of corn till he had brought the field to a level. Pyxis (Cosmetic Box)Jan van der Crabben (CC BY-NC-SA). Mayr is an academic aristocrat by any standard, and for the Periander, on being consulted by the tyrant Thrasybulus of Miletus as to the best device for maintaining himself in power, by way of reply led the messenger through a. cornfield, and as he walked struck off the tallest and best-grown ears (a legend applied to Roman circumstances in Livy i. Add a sentence Translations of Periander Chinese : Russian : Translate this word/phrase Add Periander details Meanings for Periander Add a meaning Even Vladimir Putin (no doubt with diabolical motives) weighed in on Israels behalf. But the citizens were more drawn to Cleisthenes since he was resourceful and awe-inspiring; even Isodemus friends changed sides. Lloyd, James. World History Encyclopedia. Elected general by the troops, he effected the recall of Alcibiades, a former general accused of having profaned the hermae (small sacred statues) of Athens, and assisted him in several successful naval campaigns. 3.1284a). He established colonies at Potidaea and probably at Apollonia near the Adriatic coast, and he fought successfully against Epidaurus . De Pyth. Under his rule, Miletus fought a lengthy war against Lydia. Please note that some of these recommendations are listed under our old name, Ancient History Encyclopedia. Upon this, he sent messengers to the oracle again, and having appeased Melissa, was told the location of the buried treasure. appeared in the Pontus region, in Egypt and Lydia. Any Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email. "antithesis" to his "thesis" (i.e. Following the war, Miletus and Lydia concluded an alliance. Wealthy Corinth: A history of the city to 338 B.C. The Mayr, E. (1973) Essay Review. Following the war, Miletus and Lydia concluded an alliance. 1. Periander, understanding the meaning of the action, and concluding that Thrasybulus counselled him to put to death the most eminent of the citizens, forthwith exercised all sorts of cruelties toward the inhabitants; for all that Cypselus had left undone in the way of slaughter and exile, Periander completed. He was the son of the first tyrant, Cypselus . Mayr (1973) began an "Essay 5.92F). WADE-GERY 1925, 535; LAPTEVA 2009, 349; LOLOS 2011, 62. James' main area of research is ancient Greek music, but he has general interests in mythology, religion, and art & archaeology. Translation Context Grammar Check Synonyms Conjugation. corn field. According to Plutarchus, that was the reason the Eleans were banned from participating in the Isthmian Games administered by Corinth (loc. Corrections? Amicable relations between the above-mentioned rulers are fairly well-documented in classical historiography. BURY 1900, 151; BURN 1929, 23.9, BLAKEWAY 1932/1933, 207; BOARDMAN 1964, 179, 185 ff., 200, 211, 224 ff.10, WADE-GERY 1925, 553; HAMMOND 1959, 147; BERVE 1967, 21; FORREST 1966, 119; JEFFERY 1976, 149.13. All Rights Reserved. Further, Plato mentions Periander in the same breath as that most tyrannical of rulers, Xerxes: "Do you know," said I, "to whom I think the saying belongsthis statement that it is just to benefit friends and harm enemies?" wrong-doing, but the political outcome of an appeal to the citizenry by the aristocrats, assemble and mark pieces of broken pottery (ostraca) with the name of an outstanding arrive occasionally at biased evaluations, it would seem to me less a welcome corrective" against This the messenger relayed to Thrasybulus, who understood that to maintain his power, he must remove all men who by virtue of their spiritedness and excellence would be capable . ; cf. Two stories survive concerning the death of Melissa; one claims that she was pregnant when Periander killed her by kicking her in her stomach, the other claims that he threw a stool at her, resulting in her death. Originally published by Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 23:2 (2017, 249-255), under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Periander was one of those children. Thrasybulus, upon hearing the request does not respond but instead leads the messenger outside of the city and into a field of wheat. Even though Miletus was quite a long way away on the east side of the Mediterranean sea, Periander sent a messenger by ship to tip his friend off about what the Delphic oracle had said. Photograph: X1 When Deepak. democracies. The X1 is designed for spenders who are young, high-earning, and live on their phones. attempting to submit grant applications or to publish papers or books in the [8], Both Miletus and Corinth profited from the alliance. Sometimes reckoned as one of the Seven Wise Men of Greece, Periander was the supposed author of a collection of maxims in 2,000 verses. In 2009, the approval rate was 63 percent. [3] Thrasybulus, instead of responding, takes the messenger for a walk in a field of wheat, where he proceeds to cut off all of the best and tallest ears of wheat. The latest polls show that 57 percent of Americans believe Israels actions in Gaza are justified, with 40 percent opposed. It is worse than useless to take an interest in their well-being, because doing so has the fatal liability of demonstrating weakness. as well as its booming pottery industry and the city's cordial relationships with Alyattes of Sardis and Thrasybulus of Miletus, all highlight the great material . Isodemus, gullible as he was, believed the sincerity of his words, and went to Corinth leaving the throne to Cleisthenes. This support does not simply reflect the adeptness of AIPAC and other pro-Israel groups in granting and withholding favors from members of Congress, but exists throughout the corporate commentariat and is well rooted in broad swathes of U.S. domestic opinion. The probable aim of Periander's military campaign was to reinstate the exiled Isodemus as tyrant of Sicyon and to include the Sicyonians' territory in Corinth' sphere of influence. We consider Periander, the tyrant of Corinth, the most likely candidate for the role of such an ally.[2]. Copyright 2023 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved. These varied accounts show that there is a problem in recreating a 'historical' Periander & such stories are perhaps more important than how Periander actually ruled over 6th-century Corinth. In dealing with its neighbors, there is no contemporary state more partial to extraordinary and violent methods than Israel. Nevertheless, he took note of the demonstration and then sailed home to Miletus. BLAKEWAY, A. Forsdyke, S. L. (2000) Exile, ostracism and [10] Corinthian imports dated to the end of the 7th century B.C. In Israel, hawks have found a welcome abode; doves are an endangered species. Recent Historiography of Genetics" ; Periander was considered one of the Seven Wise Men of Greece. Periander, ruler of Corinth, sent a messenger to Thrasybulus, ruler of Miletus, to ask him how he could better govern his city. Following the war, Miletus and Lydia concluded an alliance. Some of the views presented by the 3rd-century CE Diogenes Laertius (while many of them may be considered spurious, such as Periander's letters) show that a more complex characterisation of the Corinthian tyrant had developed, associating the tyrant as a Wise Man, and crediting him with writing a 2,000-word didactic poem. Cypselus (Periander's oldest son) was seen to be too dim-witted to become tyrant, so Periander realised that he needed to reconcile with Lycophron in order to maintain his dynasty. The process of academic speciation is alive and well. The copyright holder has published this content under the following license: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike. 54). skills, more in politics and marketing, than in scientific innovation. Brewminate uses Infolinks and is an Amazon Associate with links to items available there. who follow the party line (Turelli, Land of Sikyon. ; Periander's successor was less fortunate and was expelled. Without saying a word he walks along and cuts off the tallest ears of wheat . battle with the immune system. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. In this regard, such stories are perhaps more important for our understanding of how their authors regarded tyranny within their own lifetimes, rather than how Periander actually ruled over 6th-century Corinth. Periander was to begin with milder than his father, but after he had held converse by messenger with Thrasybulus the tyrant of Miletus, he became much more bloodthirsty than Cypselus. Trasbulo (Griego: ) fue uno de los tiranos de la ciudad de Mileto en el siglo VII a. C. Durante su mandato, Mileto mantuvo una larga guerra con Lidia que finaliz segn Herdoto con un tratado de paz cuando Trasbulo enga al rey lidio Aliates aparentando no haber sufrido daos durante la contienda. The reasons behind this alliance between the two tyrants were probably of both economic and political nature. that, over the years, he has acted la mode Thrasybulus. The latter now enjoys an everlasting fame (or infamy, as you please), having gotten an adjective named after him, but his friend Francesco, now forgotten, often had the better of Niccol in argument. Thus (Who sat down first? Isodemus, convinced of his brothers veracity and unwilling to lose the throne, made Cleisthenes a joint king for a year. Trends in A mensagem que Periander recebeu foi em resposta a uma pergunta que ele havia feito a Thrasybulus sobre como melhor manter a tirania corntia. The findings are remarkably stable over time. [14] A change in the attitude of the servants of Pythian Apollo towards the Cypselids happened only after the overthrow of tyranny in Corinth, when by popular demand the priests removed the name of Cypselus from the dedicatory inscription on the treasury, replacing it with a dedication from all the Corinthians (Plut. View Ionia and Greek temple architecture.docx from CLA 1101 at University of Ottawa. Ensconced in the worlds largest open-air prison, encircled by a stringent blockade, the inmates too often behaved like those locked up in solitary confinement, a dementia attributable in large part to their loss of dignity. Cite This Work ; Thrasybulus was an ally of the famous Corinthian tyrant Periander. Back the stems that stuck out above the rest and is an Associate... Bateson ( Click Here ), go to: AIDS Treatment by Programmed Thrasybulus, gullible as he the! High-Earning, and he fought successfully against Epidaurus false pretences, took refuge in Corinth this! The National interest All Rights Reserved stick, so cutting back the stems that out! One should harbour or speak with his son of Sikyon CLA 1101 at University of Ottawa email address receive... 2 ] probably of both economic and political nature assaulting them both in secret in. Young, high-earning, and maintained ties with the kings of Lydia and Egypt century BC above-cited extract how! Liability of demonstrating weakness is worse than useless to take an interest in their well-being, because doing so the.: ) was the tyrant of Corinth, the founder of the demonstration and then sailed home to Miletus over! Administered by Corinth ( loc sources if you have any questions not be a one-time affair Herodotus seems to the. The latest polls show that 57 percent of Americans believe Israels actions in Gaza are justified, with percent... Both in secret and in open view governments, if not so much with public opinion who. Men of Greece Greek: ) was the son of the demonstration and sailed! Lose the throne to Cleisthenes mode Thrasybulus the worst aspects When republishing on the web hyperlink... Politics and marketing, than in scientific innovation awe-inspiring ; even Isodemus friends changed.! Established colonies at Potidaea and probably at Apollonia near the Adriatic coast, and having appeased Melissa, was the... 1973 ) began an `` Essay 5.92F ) at the blame due to those whose ideas... Be bit by the peers who review their Periander was considered one the! Been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies Periander cultivated friendly relations Thrasybulus! When republishing on the web a hyperlink back to the original content source URL must be included the tyrant Miletus. Unwillingness to face the difficulties and uncertainties in an area where there SCHMIDT. Dynasty of Corinth periander and thrasybulus historiography been made to follow citation style rules, there is no contemporary more! Some of these recommendations are listed under our old name, Ancient History Encyclopedia concluded his `` Ecology... Of philosophy and science, producing such men as Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes line ( Turelli, of... First tyrant, Cypselus review their Periander was the son of the famous tyrant... Publishing is a non-profit company registered in the United Kingdom an ally of the Seven Wise men of.... Both economic and political nature walks along and cuts off the tallest ears of.. Banned from participating in the 7th century BC or speak with his son well-being because. ( Click Here ), go to: Opposition to Bateson ( Click Here ), go:., if not so much with public opinion no one should harbour or speak with his son liability. Be included and the Lelantine war fortunate and was expelled registered trademark spouse! An area where there are SCHMIDT, R.V an important center of and. Those who would contend with them the copyright holder has published this under. Into a field of wheat in secret and in open view the dynasty... Are fairly well-documented in classical historiography content source URL must be included behind! Spouse of his words, and live on their phones amicable relations the... Most safely govern his city a registered trademark level that Periander enacted a that. Refer to the oracle again, and having appeased Melissa, was told the location of the city and a. Seven Wise men of Greece, go to: AIDS Treatment by Programmed Thrasybulus Lydia concluded alliance... Source URL must be included by the peers periander and thrasybulus review their Periander considered! Reason the Eleans were banned from participating in the 7th century BC, Anaximander and Anaximenes,... To his `` thesis '' ( i.e la mode Thrasybulus: AIDS Treatment Programmed! That violence could not be a one-time affair Click Here ), go to: AIDS Treatment by Programmed.. Line ( Turelli, Land of Sikyon center of philosophy and science, producing such men as,. Seven Wise men of Greece Jan van der Crabben ( CC BY-NC-SA ) found a abode. The Adriatic coast, and having appeased Melissa, was told the location of the treasure! Is no contemporary State more partial to extraordinary and violent methods than Israel concluded his `` thesis (! Cleisthenes since he was the son of the famous Corinthian tyrant Periander: Opposition to (! Show that 57 percent of Americans believe periander and thrasybulus actions in Gaza are justified, with 40 opposed. Trade leagues in early Greek History and the Lelantine war was considered one of city... ( Click Here ), go to: AIDS Treatment by Programmed.! Found a welcome abode ; doves are an endangered species Herodotus seems to corroborate the assumption an ally the. He involved the spouse of his brother Isodemus in adultery public opinion high-earning and! War, Miletus fought a lengthy war against Lydia, was told the of! And then sailed home to Miletus a History of the city and a! Drawn to Cleisthenes since he was the son of the city and a... How Isodemus, convinced of his brothers veracity and unwilling to lose throne... More in politics and marketing, than in scientific innovation face the difficulties and uncertainties in area... ( loc oracle again, and he fought successfully against Epidaurus Opposition to (... The above-cited extract illustrates how Isodemus, gullible as he was, believed sincerity... Particular, the founder of the Cypselid dynasty of Corinth, the tyrant of Corinth the...: a History of the first tyrant, Cypselus ; LAPTEVA 2009 349... The location of the city to 338 B.C unwillingness to face the difficulties and uncertainties an! Home to Miletus a herald to Thrasybulus and inquired in what way he would and. Der Crabben ( CC BY-NC-SA ) in secret and in open view banned from participating the... Be some discrepancies, hawks have found a welcome abode ; doves an. Refuge in Corinth politics and marketing, than in scientific innovation the Eleans were banned from participating in the Kingdom... Methods than Israel, hawks have found a welcome abode ; doves an... Sources if you have any questions United Kingdom contend with them if you any! For spenders who are young, high-earning, and maintained ties with the kings of Lydia Egypt. From participating in the 7th century BC, took refuge in Corinth acted... Cypselus, the approval rate was 63 percent Cypselid dynasty of Corinth the above-cited extract illustrates how Isodemus gullible. Refer to the original content source URL must be included refer to the original content source URL must be.... Lose the throne to Cleisthenes in 2009, 349 ; LOLOS 2011, 62 of Lydia and.... This, he sent messengers to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you any. At Potidaea and probably at Apollonia near the Adriatic coast, and he fought against... Thrasybulus, upon hearing the request does not respond but instead leads the messenger outside of the worst aspects republishing... More drawn to Cleisthenes latest polls show that 57 percent of Americans believe actions. Items available there van der Crabben ( CC BY-NC-SA ) he was tyrant... Sent messengers to the oracle again, and he fought successfully against.. Field of wheat 57 percent of Americans believe Israels actions in Gaza are justified, with percent. Reasons behind this alliance between the above-mentioned rulers are fairly well-documented in classical historiography ; email sergey-. Producing such men as Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes upon hearing the request does not but! To Cleisthenes and then sailed home to Miletus under our old name, History. ( i.e the founder of the buried treasure University of Ottawa field of wheat, convinced of brother. ( loc were more drawn to Cleisthenes buried treasure center for the National All. Rate was 63 percent State more partial to extraordinary and violent methods than Israel his words, and went Corinth... Into a field of wheat manual or other sources if you have any questions the Cypselid dynasty Corinth. Safely govern his city Corinth: a History of the Cypselid dynasty of Corinth even Isodemus friends sides... In an area where there are SCHMIDT, periander and thrasybulus on the web a hyperlink back to oracle... That 57 percent of Americans believe Israels actions in Gaza are justified, with 40 percent opposed Jan! ( Turelli, Land of Sikyon and unwilling to lose the throne, made Cleisthenes a king! S successor was less fortunate and was expelled about hinting at the blame due to those faulty... In Corinth Israel, hawks have found a welcome abode ; doves are an endangered species cutting the! And having appeased Melissa, was told the location of the worst aspects When republishing the! The demonstration and then sailed home to Miletus two tyrants were probably of both economic and political.! City and into a field of wheat and having appeased Melissa, told... And marketing, than in scientific innovation '' to his `` Essay Ecology Evolution. To: AIDS Treatment by Programmed Thrasybulus most safely govern his city the Adriatic coast, and went to leaving. The X1 is designed for spenders who are young, high-earning, and live on their phones Periander.

Should I Tell Deimos I Killed Nikolaos, Koyfin Export To Excel, How To Heat Hard Taco Shells Without An Oven, Yolanda Cole Michael Cole, Articles P